For a web design tool with shading and a free core app, look at OpenSolar. API Access and connectors are charged from 16 April 2026. Photonik is a free web tool that also lists shading. For a free desktop shade calculator with hour-by-month shade-loss tables, look at SAM (System Advisor Model). For a free web planner from a manufacturer, look at SMA Sunny Design. PVsyst, PV*SOL, Pylon and Skelion are free to try, not free to keep. PVWatts takes a shading percentage that you enter. SurgePV is paid and starts with a guided demo, with no self-serve trial.
This is a desk comparison of what each vendor publishes, checked October 2026. We have not run side-by-side tests.
Criteria used: cost to start (free of charge, free trial or paid), shading method the vendor documents, and delivery (browser or install). Also published price, and what the tool does after shading.
This list covers 10 tools. SolarEdge Designer is not compared in detail. Its own Designer page says “no license or subscription fees” and mentions “an irradiance map and shading analysis” in its automatic rooftop layout. We have not compared it further, so this list leaves out a free manufacturer tool for SolarEdge designs. Paid shading tools such as Aurora Solar and HelioScope are on our shading analysis software list.
Disclosure and methodology: SurgePV publishes this page and is one of the tools on it, so it is a vendor with an interest in the result. Methodology: this is a desk comparison of what each vendor publishes on its own public pages, checked October 2026. See How We Ordered These Tools and Sources and Dates below.
Want to see SurgePV shading on your own roof?
Book a guided demo and bring a real site with obstructions. We walk through shading, yield, finance and the proposal in one platform.
Book a Free DemoChecking cost first? See the SurgePV pricing page.
Best-For Picks by Use Case
- Web design and proposals with shade reports and a free core app: OpenSolar. Its Auto Design page lists “Heatmaps and shade reports”, and its home page says “100% Free of charge”. API Access and connectors are charged from 16 April 2026.
- Free shade tables from a 3D scene on your own computer: SAM. Its 3D Shade Calculator builds a scene of the array and nearby objects and produces hour-by-month beam (direct sunlight) shade-loss tables.
- Free web planning that lists shading analysis, from an inverter manufacturer: SMA Sunny Design. The vendor’s feature table lists “Visual roof planning including shading analysis” in all three tiers.
- A trial of a detailed near, horizon and electrical shading model before you buy: PVsyst. Its products page lists a one-month free trial. The page calls the PVsyst 8 Professional licence “Full features without any restrictions”, but it does not state the trial’s own limits. Windows only.
- Shading with yield, financial modeling and proposals in one paid product: SurgePV. Shading analysis is listed under “Everything included” on its pricing page, and access starts with a guided demo.
Comparison Table
Listed alphabetically. This is not a ranking; pick by the situation above.
| Tool | Best for | Price (checked October 2026) | Free or paid | Shading scope fact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpenSolar | Web design and proposals, free core app | Core app free (“100% Free of charge”); API Access and connectors charged from 16 April 2026 (opensolar.com); premium imagery is pay per image | Core app free | Auto Design: shading “calculated automatically”; “Heatmaps and shade reports” |
| Photonik | Free web planning, including off-grid design | Pro: “$0 (FREE designs - pay for solar leads on demand)”; pricing page: “currently free of charge for all users” (photonik.solar) | Free of charge today | Pro FAQ lists “shading analysis”; method not described on the pages read |
| PV*SOL | 3D scene shading on Windows | 845.00 EUR plus VAT per named-user license for 1 year (valentin-software.com) | 30-day free trial (no report printing or saving), then paid | Shading calculated “based on 3D objects”; Windows 10 or 11 (64 bit) |
| PVsyst | Near, horizon and electrical shading | CHF 700 per year, PVsyst 8 Professional (pvsyst.com) | One-month free trial, then paid | 3D near-shading scene, horizon import, electrical mismatch; Windows only |
| PVWatts | An unshaded baseline estimate | No price shown on the calculator page (pvwatts.nlr.gov) | No price stated | You enter a shading loss percentage; default 1% |
| Pylon | Pay-per-project quoting with 3D shading | Standard $4.00 per project; Pro $10.00 per project; currency not named on the page (getpylon.com) | Free trial, then pay per project | “3D Shading Simulation” listed on Standard, Pro and Enterprise |
| SAM | Free hourly shade tables on desktop | Free; a free software key is sent by email (sam.nlr.gov) | Free of charge | 3D Shade Calculator makes hour-by-month beam shade-loss tables; Windows, macOS, Linux |
| Skelion | 3D layout in SketchUp with shading losses | Pro & Support Package “200 USD” for 1 license, valid 1 year (skelion.com); also needs SketchUp Pro or Make 2017 | Free version plus 15-day trial; SketchUp itself is paid | Shading losses from TMY hourly data for near shadings |
| SMA Sunny Design | Free web planning from a manufacturer | “You can use Sunny Design free of charge”; Sunny Design PRO 600 EUR per year, net (sma.de) | Free; PRO has a month-long free trial | “Visual roof planning including shading analysis” in all three tiers |
| SurgePV | Shading with yield, financials and proposals | $1,899 per user per year (1 user); see /pricing | Paid; guided demo, no self-serve trial | Shadow analysis listed under “Everything included” on /pricing |
Every price above was read on the vendor’s own page in October 2026. Taxes, discounts and plan limits change, so confirm them with the vendor before you buy.
Tool-by-Tool Comparison
Listed alphabetically. This is not a ranking; pick by the situation above.
OpenSolar
OpenSolar is a design and sales platform for solar professionals.
Best for: installers who want a web design tool with shade reports and proposals. The vendor describes the core app as free.
Not the right choice if: you want automatic shade analysis on premium imagery at no cost. The Imagery Marketplace page says you can “Start with free imagery when it gives you enough detail”. It says premium imagery is bought “per image” from a Wallet balance. It says Nearmap premium imagery has “stronger 3D capability for complex designs and automatic shade analysis”. Prices are shown in the product before you buy, not on the page. Also look elsewhere if you need a finished feature. The Auto Design page says Auto Design “is in beta” (an early version not yet final).
What the vendor documents: on its Auto Design page, pitch (roof angle), azimuth (the compass direction the roof faces) and shading “calculated automatically”. The page also lists “Dynamic solar tracing to model shading impacts through day/month/year”, “Heatmaps and shade reports”, and shading analysis “down to the sub-string”. OpenSolar’s accuracy page says the energy model is based on the System Advisor Model from the National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR). It also says NLR compared OpenSolar’s shading estimates with SunEye measurements at 81 points on eight rooftops (four in Denver, four in the Los Angeles area). It says NLR found annual solar access values “statistically equivalent within ±2.63 SAVs” for Los Angeles and “±2.69 SAVs” for Denver. Those are OpenSolar’s statements; we have not read the linked report.
Price (checked October 2026): the home page says “100% Free of charge”; imagery is the exception described above. OpenSolar’s blog post says charges start on 16 April 2026 for API Access and supported connectors (for example Xero). The core app stays free. The vendor also sells optional Enterprise Services: Support US$500 per month, Customize US$1,350 per month, Enterprise custom. The “Is OpenSolar really free?” page says the platform is free for solar professionals. It says partners, including manufacturers, finance companies and distributors, “all pay us to be a part of the platform”.
Limitations: the marketing pages describe shading at feature level. OpenSolar’s help article Generating a Shade Report says the report needs a 3D design with raytracing enabled and the SAM or MCS performance calculator. It says the Sun Access, TOF and TSRF metrics and the monthly and hour-month charts appear only when using the SAM calculator. It also says the Sun Access value counts direct, diffuse and reflected irradiance (sunlight strength).
Vendor link: opensolar.com.

Photonik
Photonik is a design tool from the team behind Clean Energy Reviews.
Best for: small installers and DIY designers who want a free web tool that includes shading analysis, string sizing and an off-grid design option.
Not the right choice if: you need a fixed price promise. The pricing page says Photonik is “currently free of charge for all users” and “We plan to always keep Photonik very affordable”. The Pro plan note on its home page reads “FREE designs - pay for solar leads on demand”.
What the vendor documents: the home page FAQ says Photonik Pro gives “panel layout, string sizing, shading analysis, financial modelling, and professional proposals”. The Pro feature list adds an “Off-grid design” item and a “String voltage calculator”. The shading method is not described on the home page, the design tool page or the pricing page. We read all three in October 2026.
Price (checked October 2026): Lite $0 (no signup, for homeowners); Pro $0. The home page shows “$0” and names no currency.
Limitations: the vendor lists no shading output such as a report or table on the pages we read. Photonik states it has 2,000+ professional installers and 50,000+ designs; we have not verified those figures.
Vendor link: photonik.solar.

PV*SOL
PV*SOL premium is a Windows program from Valentin Software.
Best for: designers who want shading calculated from a 3D scene and a trial before paying.
Not the right choice if: you need a browser tool, because it runs on Windows 10 or 11 (64 bit). Also note the trial limit: the vendor says the 30-day trial has all features except report printing and saving.
What the vendor documents: you can build a scene of “up to 7,500 mounted modules or up to 10,000 roof-parallel modules”. You can “calculate the shading based on 3D objects”. Buildings can be raised into 3D shapes from floor plans, cadastral maps (official land plot maps) and map screenshots. You can also import 3D models. PV*SOL premium can show “the annual radiation reduction (direct and diffuse radiation) for every point of the PV area and for each module”.
Price (checked October 2026): 845.00 EUR plus VAT for a named-user license for 1 year. The 30-day free trial terms are on pvsol.software.
Limitations: the pages we read list a trial, not a free tier.
Vendor link: valentin-software.com.

PVsyst
PVsyst is a Windows desktop program from PVsyst SA in Satigny, Switzerland.
Best for: engineers who want a detailed shading scene and a one-month trial before buying.
Not the right choice if: you work in a browser, or you want layouts and proposals in the same product. The product page lists simulation and economic assessment.
What the vendor documents: “Near shadings: Model your 3D scene directly or import it from another CAD tool”. Near shadings means shade from nearby objects. It documents horizon data (the skyline that blocks the sun) imported through Meteonorm and PVGIS. It documents electrical shading losses (mismatch) calculated “by calculating the I/V characteristics of the photovoltaic array”. It also documents sub-hourly simulation and a gains and losses report.
Price (checked October 2026): CHF 700 per year for PVsyst 8 Professional, described as “Full features without any restrictions”. That wording is about the licence, not the trial. The products page lists a “One-month free trial”. The shop lists group discounts of 5% for 2 to 4 licenses, 15% for 5 to 9 and 20% for 10 or more. Source: PVsyst shop.
Limitations: PVsyst must be installed on the computer where it is used, with one license per computer. It runs on Windows only.
Vendor link: pvsyst.com.

PVWatts
PVWatts is a calculator from the National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR), the laboratory formerly called NREL.
Best for: a fast baseline production estimate before any shading study.
Not the right choice if: you need to model obstructions. The help text on the system information page says the shading input is a “Reduction in the incident solar radiation from shadows caused by objects near the array”. The default is 1%. It also says “Shading analysis tools can determine a loss percentage for shading by nearby objects”.
What the vendor documents: the home page says it “Estimates the energy production of grid-connected photovoltaic (PV) energy systems throughout the world”. Version 8 adds a bifacial option (for panels that collect light on both sides). It also adds a monthly irradiance loss input for soiling (dirt) or snow. SAM’s photovoltaic page says its PVWatts implementation includes shading options that are not available in the online version.
Price (checked October 2026): no price is shown on the calculator page. The legal notice says the model “may be used for any purpose whatsoever” and is provided “AS IS”.
Limitations: the page cautions that predictions “include many inherent assumptions and uncertainties” and do not reflect site-specific characteristics except through the inputs.
Vendor link: pvwatts.nlr.gov.

Pylon
Pylon is a design tool from Saru Technologies Pty Ltd, North Strathfield, NSW (per its privacy policy).
Best for: small residential installers who want to pay per project instead of per seat.
Not the right choice if: your projects are larger than the plan allows. The pricing table lists a maximum DC size of 30kW on Standard and 99kW+ on Pro.
What the vendor documents: the pricing table marks “3D Shading Simulation” as included on Standard, Pro and Enterprise. The 3D shading page says to “Use 3D shading simulations to accurately predict solar production yield” and mentions “comprehensive shading reports”. The pricing table does not list a shading report as a separate item. Pro adds “Battery storage design” and “Custom Load Profile”. A load profile shows how much power a site uses over time. High resolution imagery is marked as available in select countries.
Price (checked October 2026): Standard $4.00 per project; Pro $10.00 per project; Enterprise by contact. The page names no currency. It offers “Start free trial” with “No contract + no credit card required”. Its FAQ says new users get “free credits for FIVE Standard Projects”, so the trial is counted in projects, not days.
Limitations: the pricing table lists 5 designs per project on every plan.
Vendor link: getpylon.com.

SAM
SAM is the System Advisor Model, a desktop application from the National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR, formerly NREL).
Best for: engineers and analysts who want hourly shade-loss data from a 3D scene at no cost.
Not the right choice if: you need customer proposals. The pages we read describe techno-economic analysis (a study of both energy output and cost) for “project managers and engineers, policy analysts, technology developers, and researchers”.
What the vendor documents: the 3D Shade Calculator overview says it “uses a sun position algorithm and a three-dimensional drawing of a photovoltaic array and nearby shading objects to generate hour-by-month tables of beam irradiance shade loss percentages, and a sky diffuse loss percentage”. Beam light is direct sunlight. Diffuse light is sunlight scattered by the sky. The scene uses Box, cylinder, tree and roof shapes. You can add an aerial photograph from Bing Maps as an underlay. The hourly table uses the sun position at the midpoint of each hour of the year. The shade data description also says the algorithm “does not estimate the reduction in diffuse solar irradiance due to reduction of the view factor caused by shade objects”. That sits beside the overview’s mention of a sky diffuse loss percentage. Read the shade data description before you rely on the diffuse figure.
Price (checked October 2026): free. On first run you register an email address to receive a free software key. SAM 2026.7.3 runs on Windows 11 or 10 (64-bit), macOS 12 or later and Linux, per the download page.
Limitations: the legal notice says the model is provided “as is”. It says NLR “shall not provide any support, consulting, training or assistance”. The About page, however, points users to a forum.
Vendor link: sam.nlr.gov.

Skelion for SketchUp
Skelion is a solar design plugin for SketchUp. SketchUp is a Trimble product.
Best for: designers who already model in SketchUp and want panel layout and shading losses inside that model.
Not the right choice if: you want a fully free path. The Skelion download page lists the requirement as “Sketchup Pro or Sketchup Make 2017”. Trimble’s pricing page lists SketchUp Pro at $33.25 USD per month per user, billed annually.
What the vendor documents: the features page says Skelion calculates “the percentage of solar energy available for each panel”. It uses TMY (typical meteorological year) hourly meteorological data. It takes near shadings into account. It also lists a PVsyst export of the 3D model, links to PVWatts and PVGIS, and tracking and backtracking with shading losses. Backtracking means trackers tilt back so rows do not shade each other.
Price (checked October 2026): the download page offers a free version (v5.5.5, April 2026, Windows or macOS) plus a 15-day trial. The Pro & Support Package is “200 USD” for 1 license, with a serial code valid for 1 year. The pages we read do not say which features the free version limits after the trial.
Limitations: Skelion is a plugin, so SketchUp must be installed and licensed on its own terms.
Vendor link: skelion.com.

SMA Sunny Design
Sunny Design is a planning tool from the inverter manufacturer SMA.
Best for: installers who want a free web planner with shading analysis and are open to a manufacturer’s tool.
Not the right choice if: you need 3D model import or export, extended project documentation or time-series export. The vendor’s feature table marks those for Sunny Design PRO only.
What the vendor documents: you open Sunny Design “in your web browser or on your iPad or Android tablet”. The feature table lists “Visual roof planning including shading analysis” in the anonymous, registered and PRO tiers. The shading method is not described on the page we read.
Price (checked October 2026): “You can use Sunny Design free of charge.” Sunny Design PRO is 600 EUR per year (net). It has “a month-long free trial”. Source: SMA Sunny Design page.
Limitations: the page we read does not say which non-SMA components the planner supports.
Vendor link: sma.de.

SurgePV
SurgePV is our product. We publish this list and sell this software.
Best for: teams that have outgrown free tools and want shading analysis, yield modeling, financial modeling and proposals in one paid web product.
Not the right choice if:
- you want a free tier or a self-serve trial. SurgePV offers a guided demo and does not advertise a trial.
- you want a free tool you can use alone today. OpenSolar’s core app, SAM, Photonik and SMA Sunny Design are free of charge as the vendors publish. API Access and OpenSolar connectors are charged from 16 April 2026.
- you want a published shading method to compare line by line. SurgePV’s pricing page lists “Shadow analysis” as included, and this list uses only that and the product scope.
- you need approval from a lender, authority or engineer. SurgePV outputs support design and documentation but do not replace that approval.
- you need a full CRM (software for customer and sales records), monitoring or ERP product. SurgePV’s published product scope does not list a CRM. Its published scope does not include monitoring or ERP.
What the vendor documents: SurgePV’s published scope is 3D roof modeling, solar array layout and shading analysis. It also covers energy-yield modeling, financial modeling and electrical workflow support. It covers bill-of-materials output and proposal generation. See the shadow analysis page and the solar designing page.
Price (checked October 2026): $1,899 per user per year for one user. It is $1,499 per user per year for 3 seats and $1,299 per user per year for 5 seats. The pricing page lists shadow analysis under “Everything included”.
Limitations: results depend on the source data, assumptions and equipment models you use.
Vendor link: SurgePV shadow analysis.

See SurgePV shading on a project like yours
Book a guided demo and bring a roof or site with obstructions.
Book a Free DemoUsing a Free Tool With PVWatts
PVWatts asks for a shading percentage and says shading analysis tools can determine it. That gives a simple way to combine two free tools. Build the obstructions in a tool that models them. Examples are SAM’s 3D Shade Calculator or the shading analysis in OpenSolar or SMA Sunny Design. Read the annual loss. Then enter it in PVWatts as the shading loss. Keep the PVWatts self-shading note in mind. For one-axis trackers (mounts that turn panels to follow the sun), PVWatts calculates self-shading from the ground coverage ratio you set. The ratio shows how much of the ground the panels cover. So its help text says not to also put that loss into the shading input.
Before you rely on the number, check it against site photos and the vendor’s notes on what the shading method leaves out. SAM, for example, says its algorithm does not estimate the diffuse view-factor reduction from shade objects.
For paid options with documented shade reports, see our shading analysis software list. If the shading result has to feed a proposal, see free proposal software. For energy and payback numbers after shading, see solar calculation software. For a primer on why shade losses vary so much by site, read how shading affects solar panels.
How We Ordered These Tools
The tools are listed alphabetically. The table records what each vendor documents, not what we saw in use. “Not described on the pages read” means the pages we read did not say. The feature may still exist.
Cost to start. It matters because “free” covers three different things here. They are free of charge, a time-limited trial and a paid product with a free version attached. We did not test any signup flow or confirm that free access continues past October 2026.
Shading method documented. It matters because a percentage input, a 3D scene and a “shading analysis” label are different levels of detail. We did not compare the methods on one roof or check any accuracy figure a vendor quotes.
Delivery. It matters because a browser tool works on a site visit and a Windows install does not. We did not test performance or offline use.
Published price. It matters because a stated number lets you plan a budget. We left out taxes, discounts, add-ons and academic pricing.
What happens after shading. It matters if the number must reach a yield estimate or a proposal. We did not test exports or handoffs between tools.
SurgePV sits in the alphabetical list like the other nine. We could cite only its published scope and pricing page for shading. That is less shading detail than the SAM or PVsyst entries above give. So it is the best-for pick only for a paid product that combines shading with yield, financial modeling and proposals.
Sources and Dates
Vendor pages were read in October 2026. Tool facts come from each vendor’s own public pages, linked here by tool. OpenSolar (Imagery Marketplace page, Auto Design page, accuracy page, blog post, Enterprise Services, “Is OpenSolar really free?” page, Generating a Shade Report, opensolar.com). Photonik (design tool page, photonik.solar). PV*SOL (pvsol.software, valentin-software.com). PVsyst (products page, PVsyst shop). PVWatts (system information page, photovoltaic page, pvwatts.nlr.gov). Pylon (privacy policy, 3D shading page, getpylon.com). SAM (3D Shade Calculator overview, shade data description, download page, sam.nlr.gov). SMA Sunny Design (SMA Sunny Design page). SurgePV (SurgePV pricing).
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best free solar shadow analysis software?
It depends on the job. OpenSolar has a free core app, and Photonik is a free web design tool. Both list shading analysis. The vendor charges for OpenSolar API Access and supported connectors from 16 April 2026. SAM is a free desktop application with a 3D shade calculator. SMA Sunny Design lists shading analysis in its free version. PVsyst and PV*SOL are free to try for one month and 30 days, then paid. Match the tool to your project type using the comparison table.
Which free tools model shading and which only take a percentage?
SAM draws a 3D scene of the array and nearby objects and produces hour-by-month shade-loss tables. OpenSolar, Photonik and SMA Sunny Design list shading analysis inside a design tool. PVWatts does not draw obstructions. It asks you to enter a shading loss percentage, with a default of 1%. It says shading analysis tools can determine that percentage.
Is there a free shadow analysis tool online?
Yes. OpenSolar, Photonik and SMA Sunny Design run in a web browser and list shading analysis. The PVWatts calculator is also online, but it takes a shading percentage instead of modeling obstructions. PVsyst, PV*SOL and Skelion install on your computer.
What are alternatives to ShadeMap for solar shading?
ShadeMap’s home page describes a web tool that simulates shadows cast by buildings, trees and terrain and builds shadow accumulation maps. For shading losses on a PV array, tools on this list that list shading analysis include OpenSolar, SAM, SMA Sunny Design and Photonik. Check each vendor’s page for the output you need.
What is a solar analysis tool?
A solar analysis tool estimates how much energy a PV (solar panel) system produces. NLR (the National Laboratory of the Rockies) describes PVWatts as estimating the energy production of grid-connected PV systems. It describes SAM as a free desktop application for techno-economic analysis. For shading, pick a tool that models obstructions or lets you enter a measured shading loss.
When is a free shading tool not enough?
Ask the person who will read the report what they accept before you choose. NLR provides SAM and PVWatts “as is” and says it is not liable in its legal notice. So a free model is your own responsibility. If the reader needs a named method, check which tool documents it before you rely on the result.
Related lists
For related comparisons, see best free solar design software and best solar simulation software. For the product behind the SurgePV entry, see shadow analysis.


