If a lender or investor will read the yield number, start with PVsyst or HelioScope. PVsyst’s help pages describe a P50-P90 evaluation tool. P90 is the yield expected to be met or beaten in 90% of years. HelioScope’s own page describes an 8760 production report (an hourly production report) that it says you can use to get financing. SAM (System Advisor Model) also lists a P50/P90 simulation option. PV*SOL describes its reports as bankable. For free calculation, SAM is the deeper tool and PVWatts the quicker one. SurgePV suits installers who want yield modeling, financial modeling and proposals in one web application. It states that its outputs do not replace approval. That approval comes from the responsible engineer, authority, lender, insurer or utility. So use PVsyst or HelioScope where a lender sets the report requirement.
This is a desk comparison of what each vendor publishes, checked October 2026. We have not run side-by-side tests.
Criteria used: what the tool calculates, report and financial output, delivery (browser, desktop or both), published price, and free or trial access.
SurgePV publishes this page and is one of the vendors on this list.
Want to see SurgePV on your own project?
Book a guided demo and bring a real site. We walk through design, yield, finance and the proposal in one platform.
Book a Free DemoChecking cost first? See the SurgePV pricing page.
Best-For Picks by Use Case
- Yield study that a lender or investor will read: PVsyst. Its help pages document a P50-P90 evaluation tool. Its product page documents sub-hourly simulation, a gains and losses report and an economic assessment. In that assessment, NPV is net present value, LCOE is levelized cost of energy and ROI is return on investment. It is Windows only.
- Commercial rooftop, carport and ground-mount calculations with an hourly production report: HelioScope. Its pricing page lists an 8760 production report. On Pro, it lists financial modeling and P90, P95 and P99 values.
- Residential production and savings in one sales workflow: Aurora Solar. Its pricing page lists performance simulation, a utility rate database and financing and energy bill comparisons.
- Free techno-economic modeling: SAM. The National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR, formerly NREL) describes SAM as a free desktop application. It has PV and battery models, financial models and a P50/P90 simulation option. It is built for analysis, not for sales proposals.
- Yield, financial modeling and proposals in one web application: SurgePV. Its published scope covers 3D roof modeling, array layout, shading and energy-yield modeling. It also covers financial modeling, bill of materials and proposals.
Comparison Table
Listed alphabetically. This is not a ranking; pick by the situation above.
| Tool | Best for | Price (checked October 2026) | Free or paid | Decisive scope fact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aurora Solar | Residential production and savings | Basic $135 per user per month billed annually; Premium $220 per user per month billed annually; Enterprise custom per project (aurorasolar.com) | Paid | Performance simulation and utility rate database on the plan list |
| Energy Toolbase | Utility-rate savings and storage economics | Not published for ETB Developer; the vendor quotes on a call (energytoolbase.com) | Not published for ETB Developer; quoted on a call | 120k+ utility rates tracked, per the vendor’s counter |
| HelioScope | Commercial design with an 8760 report | Basic $1,620 per license per year; Pro $2,640 per license per year; Enterprise custom (helioscope.aurorasolar.com) | Paid; free trial offered | 8760 production report; vendor cites third-party validation within 1% of PVsyst |
| OpenSolar | Design and proposals for installers (core app free) | Core app free; API Access and connectors cost extra from 16 April 2026; optional Enterprise Services from US$500 per month (opensolar.com) | Free core app, paid API and connectors | Energy modeling based on SAM, per the vendor |
| PV*SOL | 3D shading with battery, EV and heat pump | 845.00 EUR plus VAT per named-user license for 1 year (valentin-software.com) | Paid; 30-day trial | Windows install; 20-year financial analysis |
| PVsyst | Detailed yield study; P50-P90 tool | CHF 700 per year, PVsyst 8 Professional (pvsyst.com) | Paid; one-month trial | P50-P90 evaluation tool; Windows install |
| PVWatts | Fast first-pass estimate | No price listed on the calculator page (pvwatts.nlr.gov) | No charge stated | Few inputs; the page cautions about assumptions and uncertainty |
| SAM | Free techno-economic modeling | “A free desktop application” (sam.nlr.gov) | Free | Detailed PV model, battery models, financial models, P50/P90 option |
| SolarEdge Designer | SolarEdge systems | “No license or subscription fees” (solaredge.com) | Free | Designs SolarEdge systems |
| SurgePV | Design to proposal in one web app | $1,899 per user per year (1 user); see /pricing | Paid; guided demo, no self-serve trial | Yield and financial modeling in the same product as layout and proposals |
Every price above was read on the vendor’s own page in October 2026. Taxes, discounts and plan limits change, so confirm them with the vendor before you buy.
Tool-by-Tool Comparison
Listed alphabetically. This is not a ranking; pick by the situation above.
Aurora Solar
Best for: residential sales teams that want production, savings figures and proposals in one product.
Not the right choice if: you need a P90 yield report or a price in a currency other than USD. P90 is the yield expected to be met or beaten in 90% of years. Aurora’s help article on P-values says its estimates are P50 values from typical meteorological year data. It also says Aurora “does not natively output P90” for energy production. The prices on the pricing page we read are in USD.
What the vendor documents: performance simulation, irradiance analysis and 3D roof modeling and trees. It also lists a utility rate database (custom rates, or rates from Genability and Aurora). It lists financing and energy bill comparisons and web and PDF proposals. Battery storage modeling for backup, self-consumption and arbitrage is listed on Premium.
Price (checked October 2026): Basic is $159 per user per month billed monthly. It is $135 per user per month billed annually ($1,620 per year). Premium is $259 per user per month billed monthly. It is $220 per user per month billed annually ($2,640 per year). Enterprise is custom, per project.
Limitations: Basic and Premium list 1 user and 50 projects per month. A trial is not stated on the pricing page we read.
Vendor link: aurorasolar.com/pricing.

Energy Toolbase
Best for: teams whose proposal rests on utility-rate savings and storage economics.
Not the right choice if: you need a published price or a roof-layout tool. The vendor’s ETB Developer page does not list an in-app layout tool. It lists PV design partnerships with design software tools. Ask in a demo how the layout work connects. The pricing page we read offers a 30-minute call about “pricing for your team size”. It does not list a price for ETB Developer.
What the vendor documents: ETB Developer covers rate analysis with time-of-use modeling. It covers net metering modeling for NEM, VNEM and NEMA programs. It covers energy storage simulation and proposal creation. It also lists PV design partnerships with design software tools. Its page says it has an in-house utility rates team. The page shows a counter of 120k+ utility rates tracked.
Price (checked October 2026): Not published for ETB Developer; contact Energy Toolbase. The call booking says no credit card is needed.
Limitations: the NEM terms on the page are US program names. How the rate database covers other countries is not stated on the pages we read.
Vendor link: energytoolbase.com.

HelioScope
Best for: commercial designers who want rooftop, carport or ground-mount layouts with an hourly production report.
Not the right choice if: you design above 5 MW (DC), which needs the Enterprise plan.
What the vendor documents: its simulation page lists production estimates “validated to be within 1% of PVsyst by third parties” (the vendor’s wording). It also lists an 8760 production report “you can use to get financing”. It lists weather from 8 common sources or your own upload. Its pricing page lists shade reports. Pro adds financial modeling, sales proposals, storage modeling and P90, P95 and P99 values.
Price (checked October 2026): Basic is $159 per license per month or $1,620 per license per year. It includes 1 user, 10 projects per month and 120 projects per year. Designs go up to 1.25 MW (DC). Pro is $259 per license per month or $2,640 per year. Designs go up to 5 MW (DC). Enterprise is custom per project. HelioScope offers a free trial. Its help article gives a standard length of 14 days, one trial per customer.
Limitations: single-axis trackers and PVsyst export are Enterprise features. HelioScope describes itself as an Aurora Inc. company.
Vendor link: helioscope.aurorasolar.com.

OpenSolar
Best for: installers who want design, proposals and production figures in a core app the vendor calls free.
Not the right choice if: you need a P50/P90 or lender-format yield report. The OpenSolar pages we read do not describe one. Also look elsewhere if you want a vendor with no commercial partners. OpenSolar says its partners (manufacturers, finance companies, distributors and others) pay to be on the platform. The vendor says this is how the core app stays free (opensolar.com/free).
What the vendor documents: auto design, auto BOM (a parts list built from the design) and single line diagrams. A single line diagram is a simple drawing of how the system is wired. It also lists proposals, integrated finance and the OpenSolar CRM. The CRM sits inside a core app the vendor calls free. Its accuracy page says OpenSolar’s energy modeling is based on SAM. It quotes a PVEL finding on its production figures. They are within 0.1% to 1.9% of PVsyst estimates and within 0.0% to 0.2% of standalone SAM estimates. We have not read the PVEL report.
Price (checked October 2026): the core app is free of charge for solar professionals, per the vendor (opensolar.com/free). From 16 April 2026 the vendor charges for API Access, a per-project fee. The per-project API fee is on OpenSolar’s API page. It also charges for supported connectors, a monthly fee per organization. The 16 February 2026 post says accounting connectors are billed as a monthly fee per organization. Optional paid Enterprise Services are Support at US$500 per month and Customize at US$1,350 per month. There is also a custom Enterprise tier. Premium imagery is pay per image. The app shows the price.
Limitations: the pages we read do not give a system-size limit.
Vendor link: opensolar.com.

PV*SOL
Best for: designers who want 3D shading, battery, EV and heat pump modeling in one Windows program. They also want a financial analysis.
Not the right choice if: you need a browser tool. It installs on Windows 10 or 11 (64 bit).
What the vendor documents: shading calculated from 3D objects and simulation with battery storage, electric vehicles and heat pumps. It also lists a financial analysis over 20 years and an automatically generated circuit diagram. Project reports come in 24 languages (23 on pvsol.software), and the vendor describes them as bankable. Its Bankability help topic sets P50 as the default. You can pick P90 or your own P-value for the profitability calculation. The vendor says this relates only to full feed-in. The module database lists more than 30,000 modules.
Price (checked October 2026): 845.00 EUR plus VAT for a named-user license for 1 year. The vendor offers a 30-day free trial with all features except report printing and saving.
Limitations: the system requirements list Windows only. Financial outputs are tied to the tariffs in its database. The pages we read do not say which countries they cover.
Vendor link: pvsol.software.

PVsyst
Best for: engineers and consultants who need a detailed yield study with a documented uncertainty tool.
Not the right choice if: you work in a browser or on a Mac (PVsyst states it only runs on Windows). Also look elsewhere if you want proposals or a client-facing sales view in the same product. The product page lists simulation and economic assessment. The help index we searched lists no quotation or proposal output.
What the vendor documents: hourly and sub-hourly simulation, a gains and losses report and near and horizon shading. It also lists storage and self-consumption strategies and bifacial and tracker systems. An economic assessment calculates NPV, LCOE and ROI. A single line diagram editor and viewer covers grid-connected systems only. Storage is not included. The vendor says it is still work in progress. The P50-P90 help page documents a tool that assumes annual yields follow a normal (Gaussian) distribution. The spread comes from combining individual uncertainties in quadrature.
Price (checked October 2026): CHF 700 per year for PVsyst 8 Professional, with updates included. The shop lists discounts. They are 5% for 2 to 4 licenses, 15% for 5 to 9 and 20% for 10 or more. The product page offers a one-month free trial of PVsyst 8.
Limitations: Windows only, one license per computer. Remote desktop and server installs are listed as unsupported.
Vendor link: pvsyst.com.

PVWatts
Best for: a fast first-pass production estimate, or a sanity check on another tool’s number.
Not the right choice if: you need component-level modeling or a report for a lender. NLR’s own caution says PVWatts predictions “include many inherent assumptions and uncertainties”. It points to more sophisticated tools such as SAM.
What the vendor documents: a calculator for grid-connected PV systems. Inputs include system size, module type, array type, losses, tilt, azimuth and DC to AC ratio. They also include inverter efficiency, ground coverage ratio, albedo, bifacial option and soiling. Results include monthly and hourly downloads. Version 8 uses the NSRDB PSM V4 TMY 2020 weather data set. The page has a section for developers.
Price (checked October 2026): no price is listed on the calculator page.
Limitations: NLR notes that its energy output range reflects a fixed (open rack) system and 30 years of historical weather data. SAM’s PVWatts model includes shading options that the online version does not.
Vendor link: pvwatts.nlr.gov.

SAM
Best for: engineers, analysts and researchers who want free PV, battery and project-finance modeling. They need time to learn it.
Not the right choice if: you need a layout tool or a customer-facing proposal. SAM’s page describes a techno-economic analysis application, not a sales tool.
What the vendor documents: a detailed photovoltaic model with module and inverter libraries, a PVWatts model and battery storage. It also lists financial models for residential and commercial projects. It lists PPA (power purchase agreement) and third-party ownership projects. It lists payback and net present value. Other items are parametric and statistical analysis including P50/P90 simulations, and an SDK. The source code is open under a BSD-3 clause license.
Price (checked October 2026): NLR calls it “a free desktop application”. The first launch asks for an email address to send a free software key. Versions are listed for Windows 10 or 11, macOS 12 or later and Linux.
Limitations: NLR’s legal disclaimer says it provides no support, consulting or training of any kind for the model.
Vendor link: sam.nlr.gov.

SolarEdge Designer
Best for: installers who design SolarEdge systems and want the design tool from the same vendor.
Not the right choice if: your projects use other inverter brands. SolarEdge’s page describes designs of “all your SolarEdge systems”.
What the vendor documents: HD satellite imagery and AI-assisted 3D modeling and roof detection. It also lists automatic population of the roof using an irradiance map and shading analysis. It lists automatic stringing and DC cabling and battery and backup planning. Sales proposals include energy simulation, financial analysis and ROI forecasts. It lists integration with AutoCAD, PVsyst and the SolarEdge monitoring platform.
Price (checked October 2026): “no license or subscription fees”. The sign-up button reads “Register - No Extra Cost”.
Limitations: the page does not state the simulation engine or an accuracy figure. Ask SolarEdge before you rely on it for a lender.
Vendor link: solaredge.com.

SurgePV
SurgePV is our product. We publish this list and sell this software.
Best for: installers and EPC (engineering, procurement and construction) teams. They want 3D roof modeling, layout, shading, yield modeling, financial modeling, bill of materials and proposals in one web application. See the financial and yield tool and solar design software.
Not the right choice if:
- you need a self-serve trial. SurgePV offers a guided demo and does not advertise one.
- you need approval from a lender, authority, insurer, utility or engineer. SurgePV outputs support design and documentation workflows but do not replace that approval.
- you want a free calculator. SAM and PVWatts are listed above at no stated charge. OpenSolar’s core app is free, but API Access and connectors cost extra from 16 April 2026.
- you need a CRM, monitoring or ERP product. SurgePV is not one.
What the vendor documents: the pricing page’s “Everything included” list shows unlimited projects, shadow analysis, and generation and financial analysis. It also shows proposal generation. Confirm fair-use limits on projects. Results depend on the source data, assumptions, equipment models, configuration and review.
Price (checked October 2026): $1,899 per user per year for 1 user on the Individual plan. It is $1,499 per user per year for 3 seats and $1,299 per user per year for 5 seats (pricing). Access starts with a guided demo.
Limitations: pricing, product access and contract terms are confirmed in a written quote.
Vendor link: SurgePV pricing.
See yield and financial modeling on a project like yours
Book a guided demo and bring a site and a utility bill.
Book a Free Demo
How to Choose Solar Calculation Software
- Who reads the output. An internal design check needs speed. A customer proposal needs clear savings figures. A lender or investor sets its own report requirements. Ask it which tool and format it accepts before you buy.
- How shading is handled. A tool that models obstructions in 3D gives a different loss figure from a flat loss percentage. Our solar shadow analysis software page explains what to look for.
- Financial depth. Check which cash flow outputs each tool documents (payback, NPV, LCOE or ROI). Check whether the tariff or rate source matches your market.
- Delivery. PVsyst and PV*SOL install on Windows, and SAM installs on Windows, macOS or Linux. For the other tools, ask the vendor how it is delivered. Pick by where your team works.
- Total cost per project. Free tools cost nothing to license but take learning time. Paid tools charge per user or per license. For a deeper look at the financial side, see our solar ROI calculator software guide.
To compare a tool’s number with real output, take 3 projects you have already built. Run them through a tool. Then compare the modeled yield with the production data you hold.
How We Ordered These Tools
The tools are listed alphabetically, not ranked. We used five criteria. The page records what each vendor documents, not what we saw in use.
- What the tool calculates. It matters because a yield-only tool and a yield-plus-finance tool answer different questions. We did not compare the models on one project.
- Report and financial output. It matters because the report is what a customer, lender or reviewer reads. We did not open sample reports. We did not check whether any lender accepts a given report.
- Delivery. It matters because it decides where your team can work. We did not test performance or offline use.
- Published price. It matters because a published number lets you plan a budget. We did not negotiate quotes, and we left out add-ons, taxes and volume discounts.
- Free or trial access. It matters because you can test a tool before you commit. We did not sign up for any trial.
“Not stated” means the pages we read did not say; the feature may still exist. SurgePV sits in the alphabetical list like the other nine. It is the best-for pick only for the web-based design-to-proposal workflow.
Sources and Dates
Vendor pages were read in October 2026. Prices and features come from the vendor pages linked here and in the entries above. Each vendor page can change, so check the vendor before you buy.
- aurorasolar.com: /pricing/
- energytoolbase.com: /pricing/, /etb-developer/, /solutions/etb-developer/
- helioscope.aurorasolar.com: /pricing/, /sim-solutions/
- help-center.helioscope.com: /hc/en-us/articles/52658918496275-Free-Trial
- help.aurorasolar.com: /hc/en-us/articles/52845822086547-What-PXX-values-does-Aurora-use-for-energy-production-calculations
- help.valentin-software.com: /pvsol/en/pages/financial-analysis/bankability/
- opensolar.com: /enterprise-services/, /free/, /accuracy/, /api/, /post/free-platform-data-export-pricing/, home
- pvsol.software: home
- pvsyst.com: /help/project-design/p50-p90-evaluations.html, /en/shop/, /help/project-design/grid-connected-system-definition/single-line-diagram.html, /en/products/pvsyst/
- pvwatts.nlr.gov: home
- sam.nlr.gov: home
- solaredge.com: /en/products/software-tools/designer
- valentin-software.com: /en/products/pvsol-premium/
Frequently Asked Questions
What is solar calculation software?
It is software that estimates how much energy a PV system will produce. Some tools also estimate what it will save or earn. Yield-only tools such as PVWatts take a few inputs. Fuller tools such as PVsyst, SAM and HelioScope add losses, component data and financial outputs.
What is the best free solar calculation software?
SAM is the deeper free tool. NLR describes a free desktop application. It has PV and battery models, financial models and a P50/P90 simulation option. PVWatts is the quicker one for a first-pass estimate. OpenSolar’s core app is free of charge for solar professionals. The vendor charges for API Access (a way to link other software) and supported connectors from 16 April 2026.
Which solar calculation software is used for lender reports?
It depends on what the lender accepts, so ask the lender first. PVsyst documents a P50-P90 evaluation tool. HelioScope describes an 8760 production report that it says you can use to get financing. It also cites third-party validation within 1% of PVsyst. SurgePV states that its outputs do not replace lender approval.
How accurate are solar energy calculations?
The pages we read do not give one accuracy figure that applies across tools. NLR cautions that PVWatts predictions include many assumptions and uncertainties. HelioScope and OpenSolar describe their accuracy against PVsyst estimates. That is a comparison between tools, not a measurement of real output.
Do I need PVsyst, or is a cheaper tool enough?
If a lender or investor will review the project and asks for PVsyst, you need it. For internal design checks and customer proposals, tools such as SurgePV, Aurora Solar or OpenSolar document yield estimates. They do this inside a design workflow. Check what your reader requires before you choose.
Can solar calculation software model batteries and financial returns?
Several can. PVsyst lists storage strategies and an economic assessment with NPV, LCOE and ROI. SAM lists battery storage and financial models. Aurora Solar lists battery storage modeling on Premium, and HelioScope lists storage modeling and financial modeling on Pro. SurgePV’s published scope lists financial modeling; ask at a demo whether your battery case is covered.
Related lists
Best Solar Design Software, Best Solar Proposal Software, Best Solar Shading Analysis Software, Best Solar Electrical Design Software, free solar design software, solar quoting software and agrivoltaic design tools. For a closer look at yield simulation, see solar simulation software.


