For near, horizon and electrical-mismatch shading on a Windows desktop, look at PVsyst. These three kinds of shading are explained below. For shading from 3D objects, look at PV*SOL. For remote shade analysis from imagery, look at Aurora Solar. For commercial rooftop and ground-mount work, look at HelioScope. It has an 8,760-hour production report, which gives one yield figure for each hour of the year. SurgePV fits teams that want shading, yield, financial modeling and proposals in one web application, priced per user. SurgePV’s published scope does not name horizon import, LiDAR-based analysis (using laser-scan height data) or a named shade report.
This is a desk comparison of what each vendor publishes, checked October 2026. We have not run side-by-side tests.
Criteria used: shading method, shade-report output, delivery (browser or Windows install), published price and trial access. We also check whether design and proposals sit in the same product.
Want to see SurgePV on your own shaded site?
Book a guided demo and bring a real site. We walk through design, yield, finance and the proposal in one platform.
Book a Free DemoChecking cost first? See the SurgePV pricing page.
Best-For Picks by Use Case
- Remote shade analysis from imagery and LiDAR: Aurora Solar. Its design page documents LiDAR-based shade analysis, and its pricing page lists bankable shade reports on Premium.
- Commercial rooftop and ground-mount shading with an 8,760-hour production report: HelioScope. Its pricing page lists shade reports on every plan. It lists P90, P95 and P99 values (yield levels expected to be met or exceeded in 90%, 95% or 99% of years) on Pro.
- 3D shading, circuit diagrams and financial analysis in one Windows program: PV*SOL. Its page documents shading from 3D objects, automatic circuit diagrams and a 30-day trial.
- Near, horizon and electrical-mismatch shading, Windows desktop: PVsyst. Its product page documents a 3D near-shading scene, horizon import and an electrical mismatch calculation.
- Shading inside a web-based design-to-proposal workflow: SurgePV. Shadow analysis is listed under “Everything included” on the pricing page.
Comparison Table
Listed alphabetically. This is not a ranking; pick by the situation above.
| Tool | Best for | Shading method and reports | Price (checked October 2026) | Delivery and trial |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aurora Solar | Remote shade analysis | 3D roof modeling and trees, irradiance analysis; LiDAR-assisted modeling and bankable shade reports on Premium | Basic $135 per user per month billed annually ($1,620 per year); Premium $220 per user per month billed annually ($2,640 per year) (aurorasolar.com) | Delivery not stated on the pages read; trial not stated on the pricing page |
| HelioScope | Commercial rooftop and ground mount | Shading analysis per module, shade reports, 8760 production report; LiDAR and AI-based obstruction detection on Pro | Basic $1,620 per license per year; Pro $2,640 per license per year (helioscope.aurorasolar.com) | Browser-based per a help center article; 14-day free trial |
| PV*SOL | 3D shading plus circuit diagrams | Shading from 3D objects, 3D model import, shade simulation | 845.00 EUR plus VAT per named-user license for 1 year (valentin-software.com) | Windows install; 30-day free trial, report printing and saving disabled |
| PVsyst | Near, horizon and electrical shading | 3D near-shading scene, horizon import, electrical mismatch, sub-hourly simulation | CHF 700 per license per year, PVsyst 8 Professional (pvsyst.com) | Windows install, one license per computer; one-month free trial |
| SurgePV | Shading with design and proposals in one web app | Shadow analysis listed in the published scope and on the pricing page; method not published there | $1,899 per user per year (1 user); see /pricing | Web application; guided demo, no self-serve trial |
Every price above was read on the vendor’s own page in October 2026. Taxes, discounts and plan limits change, so confirm them with the vendor before you buy.
Tool-by-Tool Comparison
Listed alphabetically. This is not a ranking; pick by the situation above.
Aurora Solar
Aurora Solar sells a solar design and sales platform. HelioScope, listed below, describes itself as an Aurora Inc. company.
Best for: teams that want to assess shade remotely from imagery and LiDAR instead of measuring on site.
Not the right choice if: you want LiDAR-assisted modeling or bankable shade reports without paying for Premium, because neither is listed on Basic. Its jurisdiction database also covers US jurisdictions only. Look elsewhere for local permit data outside the US.
What the vendor documents: 3D roof modeling and trees, irradiance analysis (how much sunlight reaches the roof), and LiDAR-based shade analysis. The design page says Aurora’s irradiance engine provides shade values that are “statistically equivalent” to on-site shade measurement. We have not checked that claim. The pricing page lists LiDAR-assisted modeling and bankable shade reports on Premium. It lists AI-assisted obstruction detection on Enterprise.
Price (checked October 2026): Basic is $159 per user per month billed monthly or $135 per user per month billed annually ($1,620 per year). Premium is $259 per user per month billed monthly or $220 per user per month billed annually ($2,640 per year). Enterprise is custom. Source: Aurora pricing.
Limitations: Aurora’s help center says LiDAR coverage spans many parts of the United States, Europe and select international locations. Check the map for your address. The pricing page lists 50 projects per month and one user on Basic and Premium. The jurisdiction database (more than 25,000 jurisdictions) is a US list.
Vendor link: aurorasolar.com.

HelioScope
HelioScope is part of Aurora Inc.; its footer reads “an Aurora Inc. Company”.
Best for: commercial rooftop, carport and ground-mount designers who want a shading analysis and an hourly production report in one design tool.
Not the right choice if: you design above 5 MW (DC), which needs the Enterprise plan. MW (DC) means megawatts of panel power. Also look elsewhere if you need a desktop install, because a HelioScope help center article describes browser delivery.
What the vendor documents: shading analysis that optimizes layouts by the power potential of each module (design page). It lists shade reports on all three plans, and an 8760 production report (one yield figure for each hour of the year). Pro adds LiDAR-assisted modeling, AI-based obstruction detection, financial modeling and sales proposals. Pro also adds P90, P95 and P99 values, which are yield levels expected to be met or exceeded in 90%, 95% or 99% of years. Every plan also lists single-line diagrams (simple drawings of how the system is wired), CAD export (export to drawing software) and the 8760 production report.
Price (checked October 2026): Basic is $159 per license per month or $1,620 per year, for 1 user and 10 projects per month. Designs go up to 1.25 MW (DC). Pro is $259 per month or $2,640 per year, with designs up to 5 MW (DC). Enterprise is custom. Source: HelioScope pricing. The standard free trial is 14 days, per the HelioScope help center.
Limitations: one user and 120 projects per year on Basic and Pro. Single-axis trackers and PVsyst export are Enterprise features.
Vendor link: helioscope.aurorasolar.com.

PV*SOL
PV*SOL premium is a Windows program from Valentin Software.
Best for: designers who want shading from 3D objects, a circuit diagram and a financial analysis in one Windows program. The license is a one-year named-user license (for one named person).
Not the right choice if: you need a browser tool or a tablet in the field. The pages we read list customer presentations and project reports, so compare that with what your sales process needs.
What the vendor documents: shading calculated from 3D objects. The 3D view holds up to 7,500 mounted modules or 10,000 roof-parallel modules. Buildings can be extruded (built up into 3D shapes) from floor plans, cadastral maps (maps of land plots) or map screenshots. You can also import 3D models. It also lists automatic circuit diagrams and a financial analysis over 20 years. It lists project reports that the vendor describes as bankable.
Price (checked October 2026): 845.00 EUR plus VAT (value-added tax) for a named-user license for one year. The vendor offers a 30-day free trial. It describes the trial as covering all features except report printing and saving. Source: Valentin Software and pvsol.software.
Limitations: Windows 10 or 11 (64 bit) only. Obstructions are built from floor plans and 3D objects, and the pages we read do not list automatic obstruction detection.
Vendor link: pvsol.software.

PVsyst
PVsyst is a Windows desktop program from PVsyst SA in Satigny, Switzerland. For the vendor’s own pages, see PVsyst 8.
Best for: engineers and consultants who want to build a detailed shading scene and read the loss by module and string.
Not the right choice if: you work in a browser or on a tablet in the field, or you want layouts, proposals or a client-facing design view in the same product. The pages we read list simulation and economic assessment, not proposal generation.
What the vendor documents: near shadings from a 3D scene that you model or import from another CAD tool. It lists horizon data imported through Meteonorm and PVGIS. It lists an electrical shading (mismatch) calculation from the I/V characteristics of the array. It also documents hourly and sub-hourly simulation and a detailed gains and losses report. Its economic assessment calculates NPV (net present value), LCOE (levelized cost of energy) and ROI (return on investment).
Price (checked October 2026): CHF 700 per year for PVsyst 8 Professional, with updates included. The shop lists discounts of 5% for 2 to 4 licenses, 15% for 5 to 9 and 20% for 10 or more. The product page lists a one-month free trial. Source: PVsyst shop.
Limitations: it installs on the workstation where it is used, with one license per computer, and runs on Windows only. Remote desktop and server installs are listed as unsupported. The scene is modeled or imported by the user, and the pages we read do not list automatic obstruction detection.
Vendor link: pvsyst.com.

SurgePV
SurgePV is our product. SurgePV publishes this list and is one of the vendors on it.
Best for: installers and EPC teams that want shading, yield modeling, financial modeling, electrical workflow support and proposals in one web application.
Not the right choice if:
- you need a self-serve trial. SurgePV offers a guided demo and does not advertise one.
- you want to import horizon data. PVsyst documents horizon import through Meteonorm and PVGIS. SurgePV’s published scope does not name it.
- you need LiDAR-assisted modeling, automatic obstruction detection or a named shade report. Aurora Solar and HelioScope document these. SurgePV’s published scope does not name them.
- you need approval from a lender, authority or engineer. SurgePV outputs support design and documentation but do not replace that approval.
- you need a full CRM (software for customer and sales records), monitoring or ERP (business management software) product. SurgePV’s published product scope does not list a CRM. Its published scope does not include monitoring or ERP.
What the vendor documents: SurgePV’s published product scope lists these items: shading analysis, 3D roof modeling and solar array layout. It also lists energy-yield modeling, financial modeling, electrical workflow support, bill-of-materials (parts list) output and proposal generation. The shadow analysis page covers the product.
Price (checked October 2026): $1,899 per user per year for one user. It is $1,499 per user per year for 3 seats and $1,299 per user per year for 5 seats. The pricing page lists shadow analysis, unlimited projects, generation and financial analysis, and proposal generation under “Everything included”. Access starts with a guided demo.
Limitations: results depend on the source data, assumptions and equipment models you use. Lenders, investors and reviewers set their own acceptance requirements.
Vendor link: SurgePV shadow analysis.
Sources and Dates
Vendor pages were read in October 2026, and prices are the figures each vendor published on those pages. The links below are the vendor pages the entries rely on, grouped by tool. SurgePV facts come from its own pricing and demo pages.
- Aurora Solar: Aurora pricing, help center, aurorasolar.com
- HelioScope: HelioScope help center, design page, HelioScope pricing, HelioScope help center, helioscope.aurorasolar.com
- PV*SOL: Valentin Software, pvsol.software
- PVsyst: PVsyst 8, PVsyst shop
See SurgePV shading on a project like yours
Book a guided demo and bring a roof or site with obstructions.
Book a Free Demo
Field Tools and Site Analysis
Software is not the only way to capture shading. Two field options are worth knowing:
- Solar Pathfinder is an analog instrument with no electronics. A reflective dome shows the surrounding obstructions on a sun path diagram (a chart of the sun’s paths across the sky). The diagram is specific to your latitude band, which is how far north or south you are. You read the shading on the seasonal sun paths directly.
- Scanifly builds 3D models from drone captures, includes a shading analysis, and has a mobile app for iOS and Android.
A field reading and a software model answer the same question in different ways. For how tablets and phones fit into a design workflow, see our mobile solar design guide. To see how shading feeds a yield estimate, see P50 and P90 energy yield explained. To compare tools built for lender-facing yield reports, see our list of bankable solar simulation software.
Near, Far and Electrical Shading
PVsyst’s product page separates three things that other tools often fold together. Near shadings are objects close to the array, modeled as a 3D scene. Horizon shading is distant terrain or buildings, defined by the sun positions that remain exposed. Electrical shading is the mismatch loss that follows when part of a string is shaded. If your project has tall trees next to the array, or a hillside to the south, check that the tool you choose handles each one.
When You May Not Need Dedicated Shading Software
If no tree, building or structure sits near the array, the shading question is mostly row-to-row spacing. The shading check inside a general design tool may then be enough. You can also do an early check on satellite imagery before a detailed run. Dedicated shade modeling earns its cost where obstructions sit close to the array or the result goes to a lender or insurer.
How We Ordered These Tools
SurgePV publishes this page and is a vendor on this list. Its entry uses the same vendor-page sources and template as every other tool here.
The tools are listed alphabetically, and the table records what each vendor documents, not what we saw in use. “Not stated” means the pages we read did not say; the feature may still exist.
| Tool | Shading model | Shade-report output | Delivery | Price published | Design to proposal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aurora Solar | 3D roof and trees, LiDAR-based (Premium) | Bankable shade reports (Premium) | Not stated | Yes, USD per user per month | Design and sales proposals |
| HelioScope | Per-module shading, LiDAR and AI detection (Pro) | Shade reports, 8760 report, P90 to P99 (Pro) | Browser (help center article) | Yes, USD per license per year | Layout, single-line diagrams, proposals (Pro) |
| PV*SOL | 3D objects, 3D model import | Reports the vendor calls bankable | Windows install | Yes, EUR per year | 3D design, circuit diagrams, finances |
| PVsyst | 3D near-shading scene, horizon, electrical mismatch | Gains and losses report, sub-hourly simulation | Windows install | Yes, CHF per year | Simulation and economics only |
| SurgePV | Shading analysis (published scope) | Not published | Web application | Yes, USD per user per year | Layout, finances, BOM, proposals |
Shading model. It matters because a model that misses a close obstruction understates the loss. We did not compare the models on one roof.
Shade-report output. It matters because the report is what a client, lender or reviewer reads. We did not open or compare sample reports, and we did not check whether any lender accepts a given report.
Delivery. It matters because field work needs a tool that opens where you stand. We did not test performance or offline use.
Price published. It matters because a published number lets you plan a budget. We did not negotiate quotes, and we left out add-ons, taxes and volume discounts.
Design to proposal. It matters if you want one product instead of a chain of exports. We did not test file exports or handoffs between tools.
SurgePV sits in the alphabetical list like the other four. The table shows where it differs. It documents shading, yield and proposals in one web product with a published price. PVsyst, PV*SOL, Aurora Solar and HelioScope each document a shading control or shade-report output that SurgePV’s published scope does not name. Examples are a horizon import, LiDAR-based analysis or a named shade report. That is why SurgePV is the best-for pick only for the web-based design-to-proposal workflow.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best solar shading analysis software?
It depends on the job. PVsyst documents a 3D near-shading scene, horizon import and electrical mismatch. It runs only on Windows. Aurora Solar and HelioScope document LiDAR-assisted shade analysis, which uses laser-scan height data. They also document shade reports in their design tools. SurgePV combines shading with layout, financial modeling and proposals. Use the comparison table to match the tool to your project type and report needs.
What is a solar site analysis tool?
A solar site analysis tool shows how much sun a location gets and where obstructions block it. Field instruments such as the Solar Pathfinder capture the shading on site. They use a reflective dome and a sun path diagram (a chart of the sun’s paths across the sky). Software tools such as PVsyst, PV*SOL, Aurora Solar, HelioScope and SurgePV model the shading in a 3D scene or from remote imagery. They then feed the result into a yield estimate, which is the energy the system should make.
What does an Aurora shade report include?
Aurora’s pricing page lists bankable shade reports and LiDAR-assisted modeling on the Premium plan. It does not list them on Basic. The pages we read do not describe what the report contains. Ask Aurora for a sample before you rely on it for a lender or investor.
Is there a shade analysis tool I can use on a site visit?
Yes, in two forms. The Solar Pathfinder is a dome and sun path diagram with no electronics, which you place on the roof or ground. Scanifly builds 3D models from drone flights and has a mobile app for iOS and Android. Desktop tools such as PVsyst and PV*SOL install on Windows and are not built for the field.
How do I run a shading analysis for solar panels?
Model every obstruction that can cast a shadow on the array. These include trees, buildings, chimneys, parapets (low walls at roof edges) and nearby structures. Run an hour-by-hour simulation across the year, so low winter sun is included. Then read the loss by module or string (a chain of panels wired together). Check the result against the source data and site photos before it goes into a yield estimate.
Related lists
For related comparisons, see best solar simulation software and best solar 3D modeling software. For the product behind the SurgePV entry, see shadow analysis.


