Answer
CdTe is the better thin-film choice for most commercial projects. First Solar lists its Series 7 TR1 module at up to 19.7% efficiency with a 30-year linear performance warranty, while the US Department of Energy puts typical commercial CIGS modules at 12 to 14%. CIGS earns its place where weight, flexibility or building integration matter more than efficiency.
CdTe and CIGS are the two thin-film solar technologies that reached commercial scale, and they solve different problems. CdTe is a volume product for utility and large commercial roofs. CIGS is a niche product for lightweight, flexible and building-integrated jobs.
Last updated: November 2026. This guide compares them on efficiency, warranty, cadmium and recycling, and use case, using First Solar’s own product pages and the US Department of Energy’s technology pages. Where a manufacturer does not publish a number, the post says so instead of filling the gap.
Compare thin-film and silicon in one project file
Model a CdTe, CIGS or silicon module on the same roof and see how each one changes yield and payback.
Book a DemoChecking cost first? See the SurgePV pricing page.
What Is Thin-Film Solar?
Thin-film solar deposits a light-absorbing layer, only a few micrometers thick, onto a substrate such as glass. Crystalline silicon cells are built from wafers that are far thicker. Less absorber material per watt and a continuous coating process are the whole idea behind thin film.
The US DOE explains that CdTe counts as thin film because it absorbs light more strongly than silicon, so it needs thinner layers. Amorphous silicon was a third thin-film option, but CdTe and CIGS are the two that matter for commercial buyers today. For a plain-language definition, see the thin-film solar glossary entry.
CdTe Solar Panels: How They Work
CdTe is cadmium telluride, a compound semiconductor made from cadmium and tellurium. Per the US DOE, a CdTe module can be produced in under 4.5 hours, and module efficiency has more than doubled over the last 15 years to above 19%.
First Solar is the company that defines this market. Its Series 7 range includes the TR1 and FT1 modules.
First Solar Series 7 numbers as published
The figures below are taken from First Solar’s Series 7 product page, checked in November 2026.
| Item | TR1 | FT1 |
|---|---|---|
| Power rating | 525 to 550 W | 505 to 540 W |
| Module efficiency | Up to 19.7% | Up to 19.3% |
| Dimensions | 1216 mm x 2300 mm | 1216 mm x 2300 mm |
| Performance warranty | 30-year linear | 30-year linear |
| Warranted annual degradation | 0.3% | 0.3% |
First Solar does not publish a module weight, a product warranty term or a numeric temperature coefficient on that page. It describes the temperature coefficient only as “superior”. Read the full datasheet for those values before you design.
These four figures come from First Solar’s Series 7 page and the US DOE CIGS page, both checked November 2026.
CIGS Solar Panels: How They Work
CIGS is copper indium gallium selenide. Swapping some indium for gallium raises the bandgap, which is why modern devices use the four-element mix. The US DOE gives a bandgap range of about 1.04 eV for copper indium diselenide to about 1.68 eV for copper gallium diselenide, and that tunability is what makes tandem CIGS devices possible.
The US DOE describes the standard process: co-evaporation or a precursor reaction, a molybdenum back contact applied by sputtering, and a cadmium sulfide junction layer. Four elements in the right ratio across a large substrate is harder to control than two, which helps explain why commercial CIGS modules sit well below CdTe on efficiency.
CIGS cells have passed 20% in the lab, per the DOE. Commercial CIGS modules typically reach 12 to 14%. The Fraunhofer ISE Photovoltaics Report (14 July 2026) lists record lab cell efficiencies of 23.4% for CIGS and 21.0% for CdTe, and says CdTe module efficiency rose from 15.6% to almost 20% over the past decade.
Key Takeaway
A lab record does not tell you what you can buy. The US DOE puts commercial CIGS modules at 12 to 14%, while First Solar lists Series 7 TR1 at up to 19.7%. For a fixed roof area, that gap decides how many kilowatts fit.
CdTe vs CIGS: Efficiency Compared
On the modules you can actually specify, CdTe is ahead. The chart uses published ceilings from each source, so read it as “best listed” for First Solar and “top of the typical range” for CIGS.
- Series 7 TR1 (CdTe)19.7% up to
- Series 7 FT1 (CdTe)19.3% up to
- Commercial CIGS14% top of 12 to 14% range
Source: First Solar Series 7 product page and US DOE CIGS page, checked November 2026.
Module efficiency matters most when roof area is the limit. A more efficient module fits more watts on the same roof, which can reduce racking, wiring and labor per watt. When the roof is large and cheap, efficiency matters less than cost per watt.
Temperature, Yield and Why You Should Model It
Thin-film modules are often credited with better behavior in hot weather because of a lower temperature coefficient. That is a reasonable expectation, but the size of the benefit depends on the specific module and the site.
First Solar’s page does not publish a numeric temperature coefficient for Series 7, and this post does not invent one. Pull the coefficient from each module’s datasheet, then run both modules through your real climate file. The temperature coefficient glossary entry explains how the number is used, and the generation and financial tool lets you compare energy yield and payback across module choices.
Pro Tip
Compare modules on kWh per kWp at your site, not on nameplate efficiency. Load each datasheet’s temperature coefficient into the model, run the same roof and weather file, and compare annual energy and payback side by side.
Cadmium, Safety and Recycling
CdTe modules contain cadmium, bonded with tellurium and sealed inside glass. The US DOE notes that cadmium is a byproduct of zinc mining and tellurium a byproduct of copper mining, and that existing mining waste already supplies enough of both for CdTe production.
On end of life, the DOE says more than 90% of a CdTe module can be recycled after decommissioning. First Solar says it aims to recover more than 90% of module materials for reuse, and that one kilogram of its semiconductor material can be recycled 41 times over. It offers recycling service agreements priced per module on a pay-as-you-go basis, but module removal, packaging and logistics to the recycling center are the owner’s job.
CIGS is not automatically cadmium-free. The DOE describes CIGS cells as completed with a cadmium sulfide junction layer. Some makers use other buffer materials, so check the datasheet if cadmium matters for your procurement rules.
Key Takeaway
Cadmium is a procurement question for both technologies, not a CdTe-only one. Ask for the maker’s end-of-life program in writing and confirm local take-back rules before you sign.
Model your module choice before you buy
Run the datasheet values for each module through a full yield and payback model on your own site.
Book a DemoChecking cost first? See the SurgePV pricing page.
Where CdTe Fits Best
CdTe fits projects that want volume, a long warranty and a well-documented supplier.
- Utility-scale and large commercial ground mount. First Solar lists a 30-year linear performance warranty and 0.3% warranted annual degradation for Series 7.
- US projects with domestic content goals. First Solar says TR1 is manufactured in Ohio for the US utility-scale market and lists an indicative 100% domestic content percentage for current production, based on US Treasury guidance dated 21 May 2023. Whether a specific project qualifies is a tax question for your adviser.
- Standard flat commercial roofs with enough structural capacity. Check the module size (1216 mm by 2300 mm) and your roof loading first.
First Solar is the main CdTe supplier covered here, so check how many qualified suppliers you can actually source from. The US DOE puts CdTe at 4% of the global PV market and 21% of the US market in 2022.
Where CIGS Fits Best
CIGS fits jobs where form factor beats efficiency.
- Roofs with little spare structural capacity. Lightweight formats can avoid costly reinforcement, but weight and mounting method vary by maker, so confirm figures on the datasheet.
- Building-integrated PV. Facades, canopies and curved surfaces. See what BIPV means and the BIPV design guide for architects.
- Portable and off-grid uses where weight and flexibility matter more than cost per watt.
The trade-off is lower module efficiency. Before you commit to CIGS on a financed project, ask your lender and insurer what warranty and supplier documentation they require. This post cannot state their rules, because they differ by lender.
CdTe vs CIGS Decision Table
| Situation | Better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Large ground mount or big flat roof | CdTe | Higher published efficiency, 30-year linear warranty |
| Roof with little structural reserve | CIGS (check weight) | Lighter formats exist, confirm on datasheet |
| Facade, canopy or curved surface | CIGS | Form factor |
| US project chasing domestic content | CdTe | First Solar lists indicative 100% domestic content |
| Financed project with strict lender rules | Ask the lender first | Requirements vary by lender |
| Standard rooftop, cost per watt decides | Compare against silicon | Both thin films compete with n-type silicon on cost |
For how thin film stacks up against newer silicon designs, read the TOPCon vs HJT vs perovskite comparison.
How to Specify Thin-Film on a Commercial Project
- Confirm the application fits. Use the decision table. If silicon wins on every line, do not force thin film.
- Collect the datasheets. Power, efficiency, dimensions, weight, temperature coefficient, product warranty and performance warranty for each candidate.
- Model yield and payback. Use your site weather file and the same layout for each module.
- Check the roof and racking. Module size and weight drive structure and wind load. The solar mounting structure design guide covers the basics.
- Ask for the end-of-life plan. Get the recycling terms in the contract.
- Check financing requirements early. Lenders and tax-equity partners set their own supplier rules.
Conclusion
For most commercial buyers who want thin film, CdTe is the practical choice. It has higher published efficiency, a long warranty and an established recycling program. CIGS is the specialist option for light roofs and building integration.
To compare the two on your own roof, start with a solar design software model, then book a live demo to see the yield and payback side by side.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between CdTe and CIGS solar panels?
CdTe panels use a cadmium telluride absorber and CIGS panels use a copper indium gallium selenide absorber. CdTe is made in volume by First Solar for utility and commercial projects, while CIGS is a more complex four-element material that suits lightweight and building-integrated products. The US DOE lists commercial CdTe modules above 19% and commercial CIGS modules at 12 to 14%.
Which is more efficient, CdTe or CIGS?
CdTe modules are more efficient on the market today. First Solar lists the Series 7 TR1 at up to 19.7%, while the US DOE says commercial CIGS modules typically reach 12 to 14%. CIGS cells have passed 20% in the lab, and Fraunhofer ISE lists a 23.4% record, but that has not carried over to commercial modules.
Are CdTe solar panels safe given they contain cadmium?
CdTe modules seal the cadmium compound inside glass, and the US DOE reports that cadmium is a byproduct of zinc mining, so existing waste already supplies it. First Solar says it aims to recover more than 90% of module materials for reuse. Any project should still follow local end-of-life take-back rules.
Do CIGS panels contain cadmium too?
Many do. The US DOE notes that CIGS cells are completed with a cadmium sulfide junction layer. Some makers use cadmium-free alternatives, so check the datasheet if cadmium is a procurement constraint.
When should I choose CIGS over CdTe for a commercial project?
Choose CIGS when weight, flexibility or appearance decides the project, such as roofs with little spare structural capacity or building-integrated facades. For standard ground-mount and flat commercial roofs, CdTe offers higher efficiency and a longer published warranty from a single large supplier.
Is CdTe a big share of the solar market?
CdTe is a small but real slice. The US DOE puts it at 4% of the global PV market and 21% of the US market in 2022, making it the second most common technology after crystalline silicon. Silicon still dominates the rest.
Sources
- First Solar Series 7 product page, checked November 2026
- First Solar recycling solutions page, checked November 2026
- US DOE cadmium telluride page, checked November 2026
- Fraunhofer ISE Photovoltaics Report (14 July 2026)
- US DOE copper indium gallium diselenide page, checked November 2026
Where this fits
This article is part of SurgePV's Solar Technology hub, which works through the topic from first principles to the decisions a project team actually has to make.


